Something new: tall boots only

Ariat vs DeNiro Tall Boots

Riding in Ariat tall boots and curious about DeNiro? Here is how DeNiro’s Italian-made Amabile Pro, Italo and Puro compare on calf and height fit, leather, break-in and style, and when staying with Ariat makes more sense. We compare tall boots only, because those are the DeNiro boots we carry.

If you ride inAriat tall boots

Ariat

The tall boots you ride in now

See whyShop
DeNiro Boot Co logo

DeNiro

Amabile Pro, Italo and Puro tall boots

Shop DeNiroShop

You already know how your Ariats fit. The five sections below set them against DeNiro one question at a time: what Ariat does well, calf and height, leather and build, the first rides, and which DeNiro style suits your ring.

What Ariat tall boots do well, and why riders look further

Ariat is the tall boot many riders start in: it is easy to find in a store, and its range runs from field, dress and show boots to waterproof insulated tall boots for winter, and the Heritage Contour II Field Zip comes in short, medium and tall heights with calf widths from slim to wide, as Ariat lists it.

Riders who look at DeNiro after Ariat are usually after fit: a slimmer ankle, a taller leg, or a calf that a stock boot leaves loose. DeNiro is an Italian bootmaker founded in 1981 in Salento, the heel of Italy, and its boots are handmade in its own factory in Casarano. DeNiro sits at a higher tier than the Ariat Heritage Contour II.

Stay with Ariat if

you want the lower tier, a wide calf, or a waterproof or insulated tall boot for winter.

Switch to DeNiro if

you want Italian full-grain calfskin, a slim ankle and foot, or a height that stock boots miss.

DeNiro Tricolore Boots

I've just bought some DeNiro Tricolore boots. I'm a size 5.5 with short skinny calves and these fit like a glove. I tried Ariats but they were a bit wide on the calf.
Rider review · 2026

DeNiro Tall Boots

I'm 4ft 11 and I tried DeNiro boots. They fit well but they're expensive. They do them in a range of calf lengths and widths, as do Ariat.
Rider review · 2026

Slim calf, long leg: where DeNiro fits better

A show jumper in black tall boots clearing a fence on a bay horse

DeNiro suits the rider whose leg runs slim. The DeNiro Italo Leather Dress Boot, the DeNiro Italo Leather Field Boot and the DeNiro Puro Leather Dressage Boot have DeNiro’s Slim Fit at the ankle and foot, and every DeNiro style we carry has a rear elastic panel with up to 2 cm of stretch. DeNiro’s size chart sets each foot size against a height and a calf measurement, from Extra Short to Tall, with calf sizes starting at XXXS.

Ariat’s Heritage Contour II pairs short, medium and tall heights with slim to wide calves, so a wide calf is usually easier to fit in Ariat. If your Ariats bag at the ankle or stop short of the back of your knee, DeNiro is worth measuring for: measure your calf at its widest point while seated with your knees bent, and your height from the floor to the bend of your knee, then match both to DeNiro’s chart.

Stay with Ariat if

your calf is wide, or your current Ariat height and calf already fit you well.

Switch to DeNiro if

your ankle is slim, your calf is narrow or your leg is long for stock boots. Start with the Italo.

DeNiro Tricolore Boots

Have you tried De Niro's TriColore line? Those & Konigs are the only off the rack boots that have ever fit me & my 'athletic' calves
Rider review · 2021

DeNiro Tall Boots

I like my square toed Deniros for space in the foot. They feel the most similar to könig in my experience, but I'm pretty tall and have huge (43) feet for a woman.
Rider review · 2026

Italian full-grain calfskin, made in DeNiro’s own factory

DeNiro artisans choosing leather hides in the Casarano factory

Every DeNiro tall boot we carry is cut from premium Italian full-grain calfskin and lined in natural buffalo leather, with a Vibram rubber sole that is glued and stitched and a YKK 9 mm zip, as DeNiro lists them. The DeNiro Amabile Pro Textured Leather Field Boot uses a pebble calfskin for a textured look at a lower tier, and the Italo boots add an inner riding patch of buffalo leather where the leg meets the saddle.

Ariat builds tall boots for a broad price range and every season. DeNiro makes a narrower range, by hand, in Italy. The riders below wear theirs most days of the week, for years.

Stay with Ariat if

you want a lower tier, or a waterproof tall boot for barn and winter riding.

Switch to DeNiro if

you want Italian full-grain calfskin, a buffalo leather lining and a stitched Vibram sole.

DeNiro Tall Boots

Personally, I can't say enough good things about DeNiro boots. I have 2 pairs, and after 2 years both still basically look new.
Rider review · 2017

DeNiro Tall Boots

I ride in DeNiro tall boots five to six days a week
Rider review · 2020

The first rides: break-in and everyday comfort

A smiling rider in a navy helmet patting her bay horse in a green field

Plan on a few rides to break in a DeNiro. The DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot is the boot the riders below are talking about: soft calfskin, front ankle lacing, double spur rests and the same rear elastic panel as the rest of the range, which gives a little while the leather settles.

Whatever you ride in now, wear new tall boots around the house and for short rides first. A new pair should feel snug and sit high behind the knee, because the ankle softens and the boot drops a little as you ride.

Stay with Ariat if

you would rather not break in a new pair at all, and the Ariats you own still fit well.

Switch to DeNiro if

you can give a new pair a few rides to soften and want a close fit after that.

DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot

Love these boots - they were relatively easy to break in and look great!
Rider review · 2026

DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot

They are very nice and classic boots. Super well made and comfortable once broken in.
Rider review · 2026

Dress, field or dressage: matching a DeNiro to your ring

DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot in black
Amabile Pro Field
DeNiro Italo Leather Dress Boot in black
Italo Dress
DeNiro Puro Leather Dressage Boot in black
Puro Dressage

Field boots lace at the ankle and suit hunters, jumpers and eventers. Dress boots have a plain front with no laces for a clean, formal line. A dressage boot adds height and structure. In DeNiro, the field boots are the DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot, the DeNiro Amabile Pro Textured Leather Field Boot and the DeNiro Italo Leather Field Boot; the dress boots are the DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Dress Boot and the DeNiro Italo Leather Dress Boot; and the DeNiro Puro Leather Dressage Boot brings a high bow and a reinforced outer leg for the support dressage riders expect.

Ariat covers the same three styles across more models and adds waterproof and insulated tall boots for winter; DeNiro lists its leather tall boots for spring through fall riding.

Stay with Ariat if

you want a waterproof or insulated tall boot for winter riding.

Switch to DeNiro if

you want a dressage boot like the Puro, or a slim-ankled dress boot like the Italo.

Ariat or DeNiro: your pick at a glance

Stay with Ariat if

  • your calf is wide
  • you want the lower tier
  • you need a waterproof or insulated tall boot
  • your Ariats still fit and you would rather skip a break-in
See why

Switch to DeNiro if

  • your ankle and calf run slim
  • your leg is long for stock heights
  • you want Italian full-grain calfskin and a buffalo leather lining
  • you ride dressage and want the Puro
Shop DeNiro

Comparing more tall boot brands? See Mountain Horse vs Ovation vs Tredstep tall boots for three more brands we carry.

What riders say about DeNiro tall boots

Riders talk about how DeNiros fit, how soon they feel right and how long they last.

DeNiro Salentino Regal Unlaced Tall Riding Boots

LOVE these boots! This is my second pair, bought to replace my first pair that I wore completely out.
Rider review · 2021

DeNiro Salentino Regal Unlaced Tall Riding Boots

These boots are stunning! They broke in immediately and are holding up to the daily use. The fit is true to measured size.
Rider review · 2020

DeNiro Tall Boots

I second (or third) De Niros. Lasted longer than my custom Sergios, were more comfortable since day one than my Monacos ever were.
Rider review · 2016

DeNiro Tall Boots

Deniros. I ordered every off the rack boot 9 months ago to compare fit, quality, and leather. Deniros won hands down.
Rider review · 2014

Ariat vs DeNiro tall boots side by side

FeatureAriatDeNiro
StylesField, dress, show and waterproof insulated tall bootsAmabile Pro, Italo and Puro: field, dress and dressage
LeatherVaries by modelItalian full-grain calfskin, buffalo leather lining
Where it’s madeVaries by modelHandmade in Casarano, Italy
HeightsShort, medium and tall (Heritage Contour II)Extra Short, Short and Tall
CalfSlim to wide (Heritage Contour II)From XXXS; rear panel stretches up to 2 cm
Ankle and footB-medium foot width (Heritage Contour II)Slim Fit on the Italo and Puro
Sole and zipVaries by modelStitched Vibram sole; YKK 9 mm zip
Winter ridingWaterproof insulated stylesLeather boots for spring to fall
Price tier (more $ signs, higher tier)$ Heritage Contour II Field Zip$$ Amabile Pro Textured; $$$ Amabile Pro Smooth, Italo; $$$$ Puro

Questions riders ask

Ariat vs DeNiro tall boots FAQ

Do DeNiro tall boots fit like Ariat?

Not exactly, so measure rather than ordering your Ariat size. The DeNiro Italo and Puro have a Slim Fit at the ankle and foot, and DeNiro’s chart sets each foot size against its own height and calf measurement. If your calf is wide, Ariat’s wider calf options are the safer place to start.

Are DeNiro boots worth the higher tier over Ariat?

If fit and leather matter most, yes. DeNiro sits above the Ariat Heritage Contour II, and for that you get Italian full-grain calfskin, a buffalo leather lining, a glued and stitched Vibram sole and a boot handmade in DeNiro’s own factory in Italy. If price comes first, Ariat is the better value.

Do DeNiro boots need breaking in?

Plan on a few rides. Riders describe the Amabile Pro as relatively easy to break in and comfortable once it softens, and the rear elastic panel, with up to 2 cm of stretch, gives a little while the leather settles.

Which DeNiro boot is best for dressage?

The DeNiro Puro Leather Dressage Boot. It has a high bow, a reinforced outer leg for support, a Slim Fit at the ankle and foot and a rear YKK zip.

More information

More guides to help you find what works for you.

DeNiro details are as DeNiro lists them on the product pages we carry; Ariat details are from Ariat’s own product pages. Price tiers compare these boots with each other: $ is the lowest tier on this page and $$$$ the highest.