Riding boot brands compared
Mountain Horse is the best riding boot brand for most riders. The Mountain Horse Sovereign Field Boot is a favorite with our customers, and Mountain Horse won 4 of our 2026 Tall Boots Awards. Shires Moretta won the most tall boot awards, 5, including Best Overall for the Shires Moretta Gianna Leather Field Boots. For one specific need, TuffRider leads on wide calves, Ovation and Dublin on winter and wet weather, Tredstep and DeNiro at the investment end, Equinavia and Horze on value, and Kerrits on paddock boots.

Mountain Horse
Sovereign, Snowy River, Veganza

Show and investment
Shires Moretta, Tredstep, DeNiro, Dublin

Everyday riding
TuffRider, Ovation, Horze, Equinavia
Ten brands, sorted by what each does best, with tall boots first because that is what most riders mean by riding boots. Match a brand to your calf, the weather you ride in and how long you want a pair to last, then see the paddock boot picks at the end.

Mountain Horse is the best overall riding boot brand, and the Mountain Horse Sovereign Field Boot is our 2026 pick for short riders. It has Prolaze-Flexnotch technology for a more comfortable heels-down position, a full-length YKK zipper with a snap keeper, hidden elastic beside the zipper and a soft genuine leather lining.
Mountain Horse won 4 of our 2026 tall boot awards: the Mountain Horse Serenade Dressage Boot for dressage, the Mountain Horse Snowy River Winter Tall Boot for winter, made from waterproof oiled full-grain leather with a faux fur lining, the Mountain Horse Veganza Field Boots as the best synthetic tall boot, and the Sovereign.
Choose the Sovereign if
you want a leather field boot that helps you sit heels down, in a brand riders buy again and again.
Choose the Snowy River if
you ride through cold, wet winters and want a waterproof leather boot with a warm lining.
Shop Mountain Horse tall boots
Shop all ›





Mountain Horse Sovereign Field Boot
Well Mountain Horse, thanks for taking YEARS to realize that there are many of us with a brown boot obsession here in the US! I have had 4 or 5 pairs of Mountain Horse tall boots (richmond, high riders, ice riders and venice to name a few). In every pair I have been a 9 wide, I'm actually between the regular and the wide but I choose to go with the wide so that the elastic lasts and isn't as visible. These fit just like all the others but are about 1/2 inch taller (YAY, I'm 5'8). I live/work on a farm and what did I do the second I had my new boots on? I had to hose off a horse, the water immediately splashed all over the boots and left dark spots (AHHHH), not to worry though, after a quick rub down with effax they looked even better then new and the water spots are no longer visible. As far as break in goes these are the first pair of mountain horses that have NOT given me the dreaded tendon blister, I'm sure you know what I'm talking about. These however are not an instant break in while riding, I have heels that easily stay down but these boots are taking a bit of breaking in to let them go down as much as usual. Another improvement to this boot is the sole. My last pair of boots had to be resoled simply because I wear them a lot, these have a super thick and attractive sole on them, simple but classy. There are so many good points about these boots (especially for working students, trainers, people who only school in tall boots etc). They are made to last with a reinforced inner calf too. Can't say enough good things, I'll update if I run into problems but doubt I will. The color is spot on with the picture but they can defiantly be darkened. If you want brown boots these are the best non-custom option out there… yes…. better then the Ariats by A LOT.
Mountain Horse Sovereign Field Boot
Because that’s all I wear, I try to have one pair for every day and one pair that I keep for showing. In a perfect world they are exactly the same make and model, and I rotate them from show to everyday as my “barn” boots begin to wear out beyond repair.

Shires Moretta won 5 of our 2026 tall boot awards, more than any other brand. The Shires Moretta Gianna Leather Field Boots, our Best Overall tall boot, has leather uppers, stretch panels, mock laces, a back zipper and an ActiveFlex insole.
The Shires Moretta Lanciano Leather Riding Boots won Best Dress Boot, the Shires Moretta Voltana Tall XGRIP Boots won Best Waterproof Riding Boot with FlexDry waterproof leather and a full waterproof membrane, and the Shires Moretta Ortona Field Boots won Best for Tall Riders. Riders below describe the Gianna fitting a short leg with a wider calf and feeling comfortable right out of the box.
Choose the Gianna if
you want our Best Overall tall boot with stretch panels for a closer fit.
Choose the Voltana XGRIP if
you want a waterproof leather field boot for wet arenas and trails.
Shop Shires Moretta tall boots
Shop all ›





Shires Moretta Gianna Leather Field Boots
I needed a boot that was short with a wider calf and these boots fit perfectly! I tried no less than 10 different boots before finding these.
Shires Moretta Gianna Leather Field Boots
So I bought the same style and size, and sure enough they were pretty comfy right out of the box! Glad I followed her good advice about this riding boot.

TuffRider is the best riding boot brand for wide calves and first tall boots, with the widest range of field and dress boots we carry. TuffRider's Plus Rider boots won our 2026 award for wide calves, and the TuffRider Starter Back Zip Field Boots in Synthetic Leather won Best Tall Boots for the Money.
The Starter Back Zip has a water-resistant synthetic leather upper, a Spanish top, a back zipper with a snap closure and a memory foam footbed. The Plus Rider Dress Boots pair a leather upper with a wider calf and an elastic gusset. Riders tell us TuffRider boots fit larger calves and wide feet that other boots squeeze.
Choose TuffRider Plus Rider if
you need a wider calf in a leather dress boot.
Choose TuffRider Starter Back Zip if
you want an easy-care first tall boot for lessons and schooling.
Shop TuffRider field and dress boots
Shop all ›





TuffRider Double Clear Sport Tall Boots
So full disclosure; I have a very wide toe box. I often have to buy a size or two up in boots because my frog-toes won't fit, but of course this causes other problems. Unfortunately this means most traditional riding boots, which have a toe cap design that has a seam right across where my feet are the widest, are very snug and uncomfortable on my feet. I thought I was doomed to this design until I purchased these sport boots which, NOT ONLY HAVE A WIDER TOE BOX but also got rid of the toe cap seam entirely! They do not look like classical riding boot, but they look cool as heck--these are the only boots I've gotten compliments on. If you really like the super fitted top of ankle look, these are not for you (so, for the rest of us, no, they don't cut off your circulation). Oh, and the calf leather is PERFORATED so not only do they weigh less than normal classic tall boots, but they are quite breathable and great for riding in hot weather. I have very muscular calves so I always buy wide calf, and I feel these fit a bit wider than normal (but according to size charts I do not think I could go down to a regular calf). The tread of the boot is great, very thick and comfortable but still flexible with just the right grip for the stirrups. There is sole cushion and some arch support which is much appreciated. The zipper on the back doesn't have the typical lower snap cover Tuff Rider Boots tend to have, but the zipper is much bigger than my other TR zippers and seems to be very durable. I had zero break in time (which is typical of TR); when I popped them on the first time and they felt like I'd been riding in them for a year already. I'd say the stiffness of the calf leather is about medium-stiff, more than the TF Belmont (which has no stiffness at all) but less than say a typical Ariat.
TuffRider Starter Back Zip Field Boots in Synthetic Leather
Great boots all around especially for larger calves. It’s hard to find boots at a good price point that is high quality and fits larger sizes and we’re so happy we found these. These are the third pair we’ve had and we keep coming back because they are comfortable and amazing for the price.


Ovation and Dublin are the brands to look at for winter riding and wet barns. The Ovation Highlander Winter Tall Boot has a neoprene upper, a faux fur lining, a grippy rubber sole and a side zip, and its foot fits in the stirrup. The Ovation Telluride Winter Tall Boot adds a waterproof foot, a front lace and a back zipper, and the Ovation Moorland II Waterproof Highrider Tall Boot is a full-grain oiled leather country boot.
The Dublin River Boots IV, our 2026 Best Country Tall Boot, has a premium full-leather upper, a full-length waterproof membrane and a memory foam footbed, and the Dublin Yukon Quilt Boots add a waterproof lining and a cozy sherpa lining for the coldest days.
Choose Ovation if
you want a lined winter tall boot that still fits your stirrup.
Choose Dublin if
you want a waterproof leather country boot for the barn and the trail.
Shop Ovation tall boots
Shop all ›





Shop Dublin tall boots
Shop all ›Ovation Highlander Winter Tall Boot
It was -6 and 5 inches of snow last week, they kept my feet and lower legs warm and dry.
This is my second pair of tall Dublin boots. The first pair did daily duty in my barn for years, through snow, mud, and horse manure. Comfort and warmth! Durable and functional. I also bought Middleburg boots and they have not held up anything like the Dublins. No comparison. I love that you can just step in and go.


Tredstep and DeNiro are the brands for a boot you plan to keep for years. The Tredstep Sirani Dress Boots, our 2026 pick for slim calves, use soft premium calfskin with a glove leather lining, flexible inserts, a YKK back zipper and a Coolmax foot lining. The Tredstep Donatello III Field Boot has a full-grain leather upper and elastic lacing.
The DeNiro Amabile Pro Smooth Leather Field Boot, our Best Investment Boot, is made from Italian full-grain calfskin with a natural buffalo leather lining, a rear elastic panel and a Vibram rubber sole. Both brands sit at the top price tier. Comparing Tredstep with Mountain Horse and Ovation? See Mountain Horse vs Ovation vs Tredstep.
Choose Tredstep if
you have a slim calf and want a premium calfskin boot for the ring.
Choose DeNiro if
you want an Italian leather boot with an off-the-rack fit close to custom.
Shop Tredstep tall boots
Shop all ›





Shop DeNiro tall boots
Shop all ›





Tredstep Donatello III Field Boot
I rode in these boots for 9 years and finally had to lay them to rest today. NINE YEARS. Granted I took great care of them and tried to only wear them when riding but I'm still riding 6 horses a day! These were my first pair of tall boots ever and even after owning Palanti boots I would choose these all over again. I truly don't think I can go to another brand. Talk about getting your money's worth!
DeNiro Tricolore Amabile Smooth Dress Boots
Great off the rack fit - even for my tall, slim calf that is hard to fit in other off the rack brands. Soft leather - easy to break in. Nice look. Bought them for an at home boot, but they are nice enough to show in!


Equinavia and Horze sit at the most affordable price tier on this page. The Equinavia Karolina Leather Field Boots, our 2026 Best Field Boot, have a contoured fit with a tapered ankle, elastic inserts beside a heavy-duty YKK zipper, a Spanish top and boot shapers in the box. The Equinavia Men's Filip Leather Field Boots won Best Men's Tall Boots.
The Horze Rover Field Boots have a breathable lining, a YKK back zipper, elastic at the calf and elastic laces, and the Horze Aspen Winter Tall Boots add a faux fur lining and a chunky grip sole for winter.
Choose Equinavia if
you want an award-winning leather field boot at an everyday price tier.
Choose Horze if
you want a soft, easy-care boot for daily riding and barn work.
Shop Horze tall boots
Shop all ›Equinavia Ari Thinsulate Lace Country Boots
Worth every penny! Wyoming winters are no joke, and these boots keep me dry & warm. Didn’t need much “break in”. I ride in an English saddle, they fit well in stirrups.
★★★★★
I had tried on several tall boots for pleasure/cross country/jumping/walking on foot. None were extremely comfortable right off the bat until I found these at Equine Affaire in Ohio. I love the look and feel of the boot. The sole is extremely comfortable, which is what I had been looking for originally. My husband does medieval jousting and as his squire, I am the ground crew and on my feet all day. The boot was so soft and pliable, it felt like butter in my hand. Very expensive looking, easy on my wallet, super comfortable. Love these boots!
★★★★★

Kerrits makes our 2026 Best Overall paddock boot, the Kerrits Woodstock Waterproof Barn Boots: seam-sealed waterproof full-grain leather, a spacious toe box, a molded spur heel and an all-terrain outsole. The TuffRider Starter Front Zip Paddock Boots won Best Paddock Boots for the Money, and the Dublin Venturer RS Jodphur Boots III won Best Jodhpur Boot.
For wet barns, the Shires Moretta Eleonora XGRIP Boots won Best Waterproof Paddock Boot. Every paddock boot winner is on our 2026 Paddock Boots Awards page.
Choose Kerrits Woodstock if
you want one waterproof boot for barn chores and riding.
Choose TuffRider Starter if
you want an easy-care front-zip paddock boot for lessons, our 2026 pick for the money.
Shop Kerrits, TuffRider, Dublin and Moretta paddock boots
Shop all ›





Kerrits Woodstock Waterproof Barn Boots
Kerrits waterproof Woodstock paddock boots are the BEST!!! So comfortable and waterproof! They blow Ariats out of the water!
These boots are roomy for my large feet. I don’t like Ariats because they are too narrow for me. These are just perfect. The leather is supple and the zipper is smooth and stays put. Very happy with my purchase.
Rider reviews of Shires Moretta, Kerrits, Dublin and Ovation boots, newest first, on comfort, warmth and staying dry.
Shires Moretta Eleonora XGRIP Boots
Walked 20 miles in them over the Peak District. Feet were warm, comfortable and dry throughout. Light weight with good traction. Would definitely recommend.
★★★★★
Kerrits Groundwork Waterproof Sneaker
This is my second pair of kerrit sneakers. Here in soggy florida they keep my feet dry, are comfortable, wear well and clean up nicely. Big step up over rubber shoes i used to wear.
★★★★★
I literally got chills from the quality. They are extremely well made. I bought a pair for both myself and my 17 year old daughter. I cannot wait for her to open them on Christmas! I had read several reviews that recommended sizing up and I would recommend that as well. (So I ordered up from 9's to 9.5's) The fuzzy lining is so luxurious but definitely takes up a lot of room. The customer service was fabulous and so helpful. I'm am just over-the-moon thrilled with this purchase!
★★★★★
Ovation Telluride Winter Tall Boot
The front lace/back zip combo is genius. Easy to get on, easy to adjust depending on the number of layers of winter riding clothes, and perfect for my particular situation of one calf being bigger than the other. The forefoot of the boot is a little stiff and does press down on my first metatarsal joint, but that’s probably a “me” problem with my arthritis, and it does seem to be improving with breaking in. The ankle is nice and flexible and allows me to put weight where I need to, and the upper still allows me to feel my whole leg on the horse. And they are warm! No frozen toes here.
★★★★★
| Feature | Group | Best for | Lines to look at | 2026 awards | Price tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain Horse | Mountain Horse | Best overall, winter | Sovereign, Snowy River, Serenade, Veganza | Best Dressage, Winter, Synthetic, Short Riders | $$ |
| Shires Moretta | Show and investment | Most awards, waterproof leather | Gianna, Lanciano, Voltana XGRIP, Ortona | Best Overall, Dress, Waterproof, Tall Riders, Kids | $$ |
| Tredstep | Show and investment | Slim calves, premium leather | Sirani, Donatello III, Medici II | Best for Slim Calves | $$$$ |
| DeNiro | Show and investment | An investment boot | Amabile Pro, Italo | Best Investment Boot | $$$$ |
| Dublin | Show and investment | Waterproof country boots | River Boots IV, Yukon, Pinnacle | Best Country Tall Boot | $$ |
| TuffRider | Everyday riding | Wide calves, first tall boots | Plus Rider, Starter Back Zip, Belmont | Best for Wide Calves, for the Money, First Kids' Boots | $$$ |
| Ovation | Everyday riding | Lined winter tall boots | Highlander, Telluride, Moorland II | None in 2026 | $$ |
| Equinavia | Everyday riding | Leather field boots for less | Karolina, Filip, Josefine | Best Field Boot, Best Men's | $ |
| Horze | Everyday riding | Easy-care daily boots | Rover, Aspen, Chester | None in 2026 | $ |
| Kerrits | Paddock boots | Waterproof paddock boots | Woodstock, Groundwork | Best Paddock Boot Overall | Paddock only |
Questions riders ask
Mountain Horse is the best riding boot brand for most riders. The Mountain Horse Sovereign Field Boot is a favorite with our customers, and Mountain Horse won 4 of our 2026 tall boot awards. Shires Moretta won the most awards, 5, including Best Overall for the Gianna Leather Field Boots. For one specific need, TuffRider is best for wide calves, Ovation and Dublin for winter and wet weather, Tredstep and DeNiro for an investment boot, and Equinavia and Horze for value.
Shires Moretta and Mountain Horse won the most of our 2026 Tall Boots Awards: Shires Moretta 5, including Best Overall for the Gianna Leather Field Boots, and Mountain Horse 4, for dressage, winter, synthetic boots and short riders. Equinavia won Best Field Boot with the Karolina, and DeNiro won Best Investment Boot with the Amabile Pro.
TuffRider is the best riding boot brand for wide calves. Its Plus Rider boots won our 2026 award for wide calves, and the Plus Rider Dress Boots have a wider calf and an elastic gusset. A rider with a shorter leg and a wider calf also found the Shires Moretta Gianna fit after trying ten other boots. Our tall boot fit guide explains how to measure your calf.
An investment boot buys premium leather and a closer fit. The DeNiro Amabile Pro uses Italian full-grain calfskin with a buffalo leather lining, and Tredstep Sirani boots use soft calfskin with a glove leather lining. One rider on this page wore her Tredstep Donatello boots for nine years. For a first pair or a schooling boot, the TuffRider Starter Back Zip and the Equinavia Karolina won our awards for value.
Kerrits makes our 2026 Best Overall paddock boot, the Woodstock Waterproof Barn Boots. TuffRider won 4 of our 2026 Paddock Boots Awards, including Best Paddock Boots for the Money, and Dublin won 3, including Best Jodhpur Boot with the Venturer RS Jodhpur Boots III.
More guides to help you find what works for you.
Still deciding?
Guides to help you pick the right boots for your leg and your riding.
Brand product information, our 2026 Tall Boots and Paddock Boots Awards and rider reviews. Price tiers compare these brands with each other, using the median list price of each brand's women's field and dress boots: $ is the lowest group (Equinavia and Horze), $$ the next (Mountain Horse, Shires Moretta, Ovation and Dublin), $$$ the next (TuffRider, whose range runs from Starter boots to premium lines) and $$$$ the highest (Tredstep and DeNiro).